商业研究

• 货币金融 • 上一篇    下一篇

我国信用评级机构是否存在“顺周期”行为?

张时坤   

  1. (商丘师范学院 经济管理学院,河南 商丘476000)
  • 收稿日期:2018-12-03 出版日期:2019-03-16
  • 作者简介:张时坤(1984-),男,河南商丘人,商丘师范学院经济管理学院讲师,金融学博士,研究方向:资本市场。
  • 基金资助:
    国家社科基金一般项目,项目编号:17BJL056;河南省高校科技创新团队支持计划资助项目,项目编号:19IRTSTHN016。

Do Credit Rating Agencies Have the “Pro-Cyclical” Behaviour?

ZHANG Shi-kun   

  1. (School of Economics and Management,Shangqiu Normal University,Shangqiu 476000,China)
  • Received:2018-12-03 Online:2019-03-16

摘要: 信用评级制度旨在为投资者提供真实有效的信息,改善市场“信息不对称”问题,从而提升市场的交易效率,但评级的真实性在“发行人”付费模式下有待商榷。基于2010-2017年的信用债券交易数据,本文对信用评级机构的评级结果进行检验,发现信用评级机构在对发行人评定评级时存在“顺周期”行为,即经济繁荣时期评级机构具有高估主体评级的正向“冲动”,这一行为在对国有企业、处于高速增长时期的主体以及高偿债能力企业中更为明显;评级市场寡头竞争以及低评级主体的“评级购买”行为,或是推动评级机构高估评级的重要因素。因此,保证信用评级的真实性的关键在于消除评级机构的激励扭曲机制,提升综合信誉机制对评级机构行为的约束,增加评级透明度。

关键词: 信用评级机构, 顺周期, 评级高估, 评级购买

Abstract: The credit rating system aims to provide investors with real and effective information to improve the market′s “information asymmetry” and thus improve the trading efficiency of the market. However, under the “Issuer” payment model, the authenticity of the rating is questionable. Based on the credit bond transaction data from 2010 to 2017, this report examines the rating results of the credit rating agencies,finding credit rating agencies have “Pro-cyclical” behavior when they are rating. That is, the rating agencies have a positive “impulse” of overestimating the subjects during the economic boom period,and this behavior is especially obvious in the samples of state-owned enterprises, the samples in the period of rapid growth and the samples which have strong debt repayment abilities; the oligopolistic competition in the rating market and the “rated purchase” behavior of low-rated entities may be an important reason for the rating agencies to overestimate the rating. Therefore, in order to ensure the authenticity of credit rating, the key method is to eliminate the incentive distortion mechanism of rating agencies, improve the constraint of comprehensive credit mechanism on the behavior of rating agencies, and increase the transparency of rating system.

Key words: credit rating agencies, Pro-cyclical;rating overestimation;rating purchase