商业研究

• 商经理论 • 上一篇    下一篇

多频视角的国际石油市场间关联非一致性的检验 ——基于小波变换和互谱的分析

郭利宁,黄运成   

  1. (同济大学 经济与管理学院,上海201804)
  • 收稿日期:2018-11-19 出版日期:2019-03-16
  • 作者简介:郭利宁(1985-),男,山东济宁人,同济大学经济与管理学院博士研究生,研究方向:资本市场风险管理;黄运成(1956-),男,江苏连云港人,同济大学经济与管理学院教授,博士生导师,研究方向:资本市场监管。

Test of Inconsistency of Co-movement of International Oil Markets at Muti- ScaleTime-Frequency:An Analysis based on Wavelet Transform and Coherence

GUO Li-ning, HUANG Yun-cheng   

  1. (School of Economics and Management, Tongji University, Shanghai 201804, China)
  • Received:2018-11-19 Online:2019-03-16

摘要: 近些年国际石油市场间价格走势表现出了非一致性现象,引发了对市场间关联一致性传统论断的质疑。借助小波变换与互谱分析方法,选取2006-2016年三个国际石油市场WTI-LLS-Brent价格日数据进行关联性研究,实证结果显示不同频率视角下市场关联呈现非一致特征:各高频分量的关联性随频率降低而增强,低频趋势序列和原价格序列的格兰杰因果检验结果相差较大;高频信号所蕴含的信息有助于预测市场短期走势,而石油市场价格长期走势难以预测。研究表明金融因素对高频联动性有短期的影响,而供求关系的改变对市场联动性的影响较为深远,政策变动对市场联动性影响不明显。由于市场性质和区位因素不同,各市场对不同类型冲击反应不一造成了关联非一致现象。研究提示,应在甄别影响关联性因素的基础上有针对性的采用不同的市场调节手段,同时应推进现货市场建设注重完善石油市场体系,使得抵御外部冲击的市场风险管理手段多样化。

关键词: 风险管理, 关联性, 小波变换, Copula, 互谱分析

Abstract: In recent years, the price trend among international oil markets has shown inconsistency, which raises doubts about the traditional assertion of the consistency of inter-market linkages.With the help of wavelet transform and cross-spectral analysis, this paper chooses WTI-LLS-Brent daily price data of three international oil markets from 2006 to 2016 for correlation study.Empirical results show that market correlation is inconsistent in different frequency perspectives:the correlation of each high frequency component increases with the decrease of frequency, and the Granger causality test results of the low frequency trend series and the original price series are quite different;the information contained in the high frequency signal helps to predict the short-term trend of the market, while the long-term trend of the oil market price is difficult to predict.Research shows that financial factors have short-term impact on high-frequency linkage, while changes in supply and demand have far-reaching impact on market linkage, while policy changes have no obvious impact on market linkage. Because of the different nature of the market and location factors, different market responses to different types of shocks have resulted in inconsistent correlations.The study suggests that different market regulation measures should be adopted on the basis of identifying the relevant factors. At the same time, we should promote the construction of spot market and pay attention to improving the oil market system so as to diversify the means of market risk management to withstand external shocks.

Key words: risk management, co-movement, wavelet transform, Copula, Wavelet coherency